CS140 Lecture notes -- Topcoder


In your labs, I will give you one to three topcoder problems to solve. In this set of lecture notes, I will go over an example of how I anticipate that you solve a problem.

Suppose in lab, I say to do "SRM 564, D2, 250-pointer". This is how you do it. I'm assuming that you already have a topcoder account. First, download the top coder arena by going to http://www.topcoder.com/contest/arena/ContestAppletProd.jnlp . Select "topcoder Arena" and it will launch the competition applet. That may require you to download some Java software. Go ahead and do what you have to do. If you are on a Windows machine, skip to here.

If you are on a Mac, you may find that a window pops up saying:

If this happens, you will need to go to your Downloads folder, find the ContestAppletProd.jnlp file, and "right click" on it by holding down the Control key and the mouse button simultaneously. You will now get a pop-up window asking if you want to open this app, which is from an unidentified developer. Click "Open".

Annoyingly, you will probably get another error window if you are on a Mac:

If this happens, go to the "apple" in the upper left corner of your screen and follow these instructions:

  1. select "System Preferences."
  2. Find the Java icon near the bottom of the window that pops up and double click on it.
  3. Click on the Security tab
  4. Find the "Exception Site List" and click on the "Edit Site List..." button.
  5. Click the "Add" button in the window that pops up and then enter "http://www.topcoder.com".
  6. Hit "Ok". You will be warned one last time about the dangers of adding this "unsecure" site. Hit "continue" and you should be able to get the Top Coder Arena to work properly.
Now continue with the instructions below.

Once the arena comes up, enter your login information. Once you log in, you'll be in the main lobby with a window like this:

Click on "Practice Rooms", then "SRMs", and then find "SRM 564," just like I do below. The SRM's are numbered consecutively, so it shouldn't take you too long to find the right one:

That will bring you to the competition arena for SRM 564, D2 ("SRM" stands for "single round match."). Each SRM has two divisions. Division one is hard, and division two is easier. In this class we'll focus on D2 problems for the most part. Now, the "Select one" drop box typically has three problems to try, with differing point values -- below, I'm choosing the 250-point problem:

This pops up a new window which you may have to mess with to see everything. However, it will have two sub-windows. One has a problem description, and one has a programming area:

The problem statement tells you what problem to solve. In this one, you'll be given a string, and you need to state whether it is a palindrome, a "faux" palindrome, or neither. If you scroll the top sub-window, you'll see a "Definition".

What this says is that you need to define a C++ class called FauxPalindromes, and that class needs to have a public method called classifyIt. It will have one parameter, which is the input string, and it must output a string.

If you scroll further, you'll see "Constraints," which tell you constraints on the input. The constraints are often helpful for finding a solution. Then after the constraints, you'll see "Examples":

The examples are usually very helpful, but beware of proof-by-Cosmo. It's very easy to get all of the examples right and still have a program that's wrong.

Now, you want to start coding. The first thing you need to do is define the class and the method, and then below that, implement the method. I do that below. My program isn't correct, but I just want to get something compiling. I personally don't like to implement methods inside my class definition. That's why my implementation is below the definition:

You'll also notice that I've changed the name of the parameter twice. In the problem description, it's "word." In my class definition, it's "s" and in my implementation, it's "w." That's perfectly fine -- as long as the types match the definition, I can name them anything I want.

I click "Save", to save the program on topcoder's server, and then "Compile" for topcoder's server to compile the program. My compilation doesn't work:

String doesn't name a type? Oh -- I forgot my include statements. I fix that and my compilation still fails. You can see my include statements there behind the "compile result" window:

I have a bug on line 10, and I can't really read what it is. When I enlarge the "compile result" bug, I see the whole thing:

This is one of those frustrating bugs when you're just starting out. It says that ClassifyIt is not defined in the class, but it looks as though I've defined it. The problem is that I've capitalized the "C" in my implementation, but not in the class definition. I go back to the "Problem Statement" window and see that the "C" should be lower case, so I fix it.

Now I compile, and I still get the warning that I'm not not using w, but that's ok -- I just want to get something compiling. After you have successfully compiled, you can test your program with "Test." That allows you to test each example, and you can enter your own input if you want as well. Here, I get ready to test Example 0:

I click OK, and it shows me the results:

I got it right!!!! That's just because ANA happens to be a palindrome. Obviously, if I try example 1 it will fail. You'll also note that it tells you execution time -- your program has to run in under 2 seconds. That can be a challenge with some programs, but not this one.

Ok -- I program up a solution with the following strategy (which is incorrect, by the way). I'm going to create a string t, which is created from the non-repeating characters of w. I'll test t to see if it's a palindrome. If not, I return "NOT EVEN FAUX." If it is, then I test to see if t equals w. If so, then the original is a palindrome, so I return "PALINDROME." If t doesn't equal w, then it's "FAUX."

You'll note that I have a cout statement that prints w and t. Topcoder ignores print statements, which is nice. It compiles with no warnings or errors:

It works fine on examples 0 and 1 -- here's the output window of example 1. You can see the my cout statement there in "Standard Output":

Since Topcoder competitions are timed, I decide that my program has to be right, so I click "Submit" and submit it. It tells me that I received 213.41 points!!

Now, just because submission is sucessful doesn't mean that your program is correct. You need to close your program window and click on "Run System Test," which is under "Practice Options:"

Now the Topcoder servers run a battery of tests on your program, and if any test is incorrect, you get a zero. It's hard on the self-esteem, and it's what has just happened to me:

Looks like I've got a few cases wrong. You can double-click on any of the test cases, and it will tell you the input, the expected output and your output (on my Mac the test case window sometimes is buried and I have to close a few windows before I see it):

Yup. That should have returned "FAUX." Test case #3 happens to be an example, so I reopen the programming window and test example 3:

Hmmm. T looks correct, and it is indeed a palindrome. What gives? When I probe further, I realize that I'm testing w[i] and w[j] inside my while loop, when I should be testing t[i] and t[j]. Duh. So, I fix it, test example 3, and submit:

You can see the bug fix there in the coding area. I'm going to be assessed a 10% resubmission penalty. So it goes:

177.22 isn't that bad. I close the window and run the system test again:

DANG IT!!!! I double-click test case 4 and see the following:

Oh. If the original is a palindrome with repeated letters, you need to report that as a palindrome and not a faux palindrome. My fix for this is, in my opinion, inelegant. Before constructing t, I simply test to see if w is a palindrome:

Compile, test, submit. Yes, another 10% penalty:

That's a sucky score for such an easy program. Whatever.

After a few seconds of anxiety, I see that the system test has passed:

YAY!


A few comments from Dr. BVZ about Top Coder

There can be a few "gotcha's" with Top Coder that you need to be careful about:

  1. The default language for a problem is Java. Make sure that you click the radio button for C++ instead. I have found that if I forget to click the C++ button, that sometimes TopCoder gets confused and still gives me a Java file after I click over to C++. In that case you may have to have a TA help you with setting up the correct function prototype for the problem, because it may differ from the Java function prototype.

  2. Make sure that you always save and compile before you submit, and make sure you always save, compile, and submit before you test. If you simply save and test, or save, compile, and test, then Top Coder uses your old code rather than your updated code.

  3. If one or more of the test cases causes your code to enter an infinite loop, then the Test suite can take a long time to execute (60 seconds or more). It will eventually return because the testing procedure times out. You just have to be patient.

Your submission scores are primarily determined by how quickly you are able to submit a working program. If you write a beautiful solution but it takes you a long time, you will get a lower score than if you write an icky program that takes you 5 minutes to write. As Dr. Plank says in his notes below, you should know when you're writing bad code for speed, and when it's important to slow down and write good code (like on your homework).


A few comments from Dr. Plank about Topcoder

Ok -- now having gone through that example, I'll make a few comments. First, Topcoder's default editor is awful. I can guarantee you that this is the last time you'll see me use it. I use the "FileEdit" editor, but there are some others that are supported by Topcoder. The steps for switching to the FileEdit editor are detailed here. The steps say that you may need to change the policy file settings for Java. Try putting the instructions specified by the top coder page in a file named .java.policy and put it in your home directory. If that fails, you will probably need to talk to a TA. You will also need to download the FileEdit.jar file to your computer.

I've written some supporting programs too -- they are documented in my CS302 topcoder page: http://web.eecs.utk.edu/~plank/plank/classes/cs302/topcoder.html. I don't really care if you use them or not, but you'll probably want to use something better than Topcoder's default editor.

Topcoder problems utilize two skills: problem solving and programming. Typically, the hard part is the problem solving, and often pencil and paper are better tools for solving the problem than a computer. When you've solved the problem, you have to program it. For me, that part is usually trivial once I've figured out how to solve the problem. For you, it will be harder, because you are learning, but I want you to get practice. This is why we do Topcoder in labs.

A final caveat. Topcoder has two flaws as a teaching device. The first is that you're so focused on speed that you write icky programs. For example, in the program above, I should have written a palindrome testing procedure. Then I could call it on w, then if necessary create t and call it on t. That would be cleaner, and it would be less bug prone because I'm not writing two separate palindrome testers. I'm not too worried about this flaw. You should know when you're writing bad code for speed, and when you should slow down to write good code. I.e., your homeworks should have good code.

The second flaw is that you have a mistake, and instead of slowing down to figure it out, you simply make random changes to your program until it passes the system test. When you do that, you are not learning anything, so I really want to recommend that you don't do it. Slow down, and figure out what's wrong.